Best Coffee Percolators: The Best Stovetop and Electric Models of 2019

Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker
Farberware 12-Cup Percolator, Stainless Steel, FCP412
Farberware 2-4-Cup Percolator, Stainless Steel,  FCP240
Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator - 8 Cup,...
Bialetti 06973 Mini Express Stovetop espresso percolator, 2-Cup, Aluminum
Our Score
9.1
8.8
8.4
8.8
8.5
MSRP
$44.00
$50.98
$44.09
$20.50
$25.66
Percolator Type
Electric
Electric
Electric
Stovetop
Stovetop
Size
12 cups
12 cups
4 Cups
8 cups
2 cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker
Our Score
9.1
MSRP
$44.00
Percolator Type
Electric
Size
12 cups
Material
Stainless Steel
More Information
Farberware 12-Cup Percolator, Stainless Steel, FCP412
Our Score
8.8
MSRP
$50.98
Percolator Type
Electric
Size
12 cups
Material
Stainless Steel
More Information
Farberware 2-4-Cup Percolator, Stainless Steel,  FCP240
Our Score
8.4
MSRP
$44.09
Percolator Type
Electric
Size
4 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
More Information
Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator - 8 Cup,...
Our Score
8.8
MSRP
$20.50
Percolator Type
Stovetop
Size
8 cups
Material
Stainless Steel
More Information
Bialetti 06973 Mini Express Stovetop espresso percolator, 2-Cup, Aluminum
Our Score
8.5
MSRP
$25.66
Percolator Type
Stovetop
Size
2 cups
Material
Stainless Steel
More Information

Note: Our comparison table only shows our top 5 picks. You can find the other recommendations within this article.

Back in the days, percolation was a common method when it came to brewing coffee. For decades, this particular slow, traditional brewing technique was quite popular in the West. Until the Drip Coffee Maker sprang into existence.

But something quite unusual happened along the way. It gave rise to a new breed of coffee aficionados who, not so impressed with drip coffee, rediscovered and resuscitated the percolator. And this is how you have the best coffee percolator at your disposal today. 

#1 Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker Review

As you can read in the product title, it’s a stainless steel percolator. Stainless steel and not plastic! 

Now that’s fantastic news given how some coffee makers combine stainless steel with some plastic parts. 

So this is how the Presto 02811 sets the stage for you.

It’s an electric coffee maker you can use to prepare your daily java, irrespective of the coffee beans you decide to use. 

The final result is steamy and hot coffee.

You can even prepare small batches if you like without worrying about not being able to achieve the full-pot heavenly taste. 

It’s weird how other brewers don’t offer a great-tasting outcome with partial pots. 

But, fortunately, this 12-cup coffee maker doesn’t really have a problem with how many cups you want to make.

The coffee machine is convenient and user-friendly to handle. No more having to fill water in the reservoir, use basket filters, measure grounds, or try to figure out how many buttons to press for brewing. 

That’s the beauty of well-designed and easy-to-use percolators like this one.

The Presto 02811 automatically keeps your freshly prepared coffee hot after the brewing process. The spout of the percolator enables easy pouring. 

Then there’s the ready-to-plug-in perk tube and filter basket that require no extra efforts.

Additionally, the indicator light notifies you when the brewing is complete. That means no more guesswork when making coffee. 

The whole experience is quite commendable if you ask me. Except maybe for the aluminum parts, which you cannot expect to be as solid as stainless steel.

#2 Farberware 12-Cup Stainless Steel FCP412 Percolator

When choosing an electric percolator, you have to keep certain features in mind.

Basics like an automatic mode for keeping the brew warm, cool-touch base, lid, and handle, detachable cord, etc. So does the Farberware FCP412 Percolator live up to those standards?

Oh yes, this 12-cup stainless steel wonder does.

The stainless steel structure is a durable one by the way. That means you can expect the coffee maker to last for a very long time.

It maintains the brewing speed on a consistent basis. This speed is 1 cup per minute; not that long even for a busy coffee lover.

Like you already know, there’s a cool-touch lid, handle, and base. Along with the automatic mode that keeps your drink warm post-brewing.

On a closer look, I happened to notice that the edges of the percolator are rolled for easy and safe handling.

Then there’s the removable power cord, which you must know is not long enough. Minus points for that!

How about the performance part?

That you can smell in the form of robust aroma and taste in the form of robust flavor.

The taste of the coffee is great, no doubt.

You’ll simply love how you can leave the percolator plugged in for hours and still expect your precious caffeine-infused drink to not taste nasty or burnt.

In my opinion, it’s the ultimate electric percolator.

The element and thermostat design has improved over the years without straying away from the original series.

As a matter of fact, this new design features some exceptional advantages like a solid, leak-free bottom plate that has no seals or fittings. You’ll love this Farberware!

#3 Farberware 2-4-Cup Stainless Steel FCP240 Percolator

Farberware 2-4-Cup Stainless Steel FCP240 Percolator

Yet another phenomenal creation by Farberware!

But this one’s the most suitable for small batches.

You yourself will understand it once you see the small size of the FCP240 percolator.

It may be small (just 2-4 cups) but the function and flavor this durable stainless steel brewer delivers are quite exceptional.

Fill the unit to its maximum brewing capacity, and you get enough for a big cup of coffee, twice.

Once again, you’ll be pretty impressed with the percolator.

If you ask me, there aren’t any major differences between this and any other usual percolator.

The FCP240 works like a racehorse by the way. And fast is great if you’re always in a hurry to get your coffee ready.

By fast, I mean 2-3 minutes, which is way better than 10-15 minutes in the case of others.

It’s an electric percolator you can carry with you on your next vacation.

The removable cord can be packed separately.

Although it does limit your range of motion due to the short length.

But the ergonomically designed and positioned handle makes up for this flaw.

Safe transport and pouring are what it does best.

Plus, the handle and lid are cool to touch.

Truth be told, this runs among the fastest electric percolators on the battlefield.

Preparing a full batch with the FCP240 doesn’t take very long.

No matter how clumsy you are in your kitchen!

I would like to talk about another drawback here.

The percolator’s heating element is susceptible to failure.

So please make sure you get the warranty.

#4 Hamilton Beach 40616 Stainless-Steel 12-Cup Electric Percolator

Hamilton Beach 40616 Stainless-Steel 12-Cup Electric Percolator Review

Hamilton Beach is another popular household name when it comes to kitchen appliances.

Their range of percolators is decent in terms of performance and price.

Once you lay your eyes on it, you’ll notice that it doesn’t look the same as most other percolators.

The retro design and twist-lock lid are unique features in this category. The latter is very useful to keep the top down.

Then there’s the drip-free structure of the spout that makes pouring a mess-free and convenient task.

The size of the 40616 percolator is larger than usual, which might feel like a drawback if your kitchen is compact.

But think of it this way; it’s the large size that paves the way for brewing 12 cups at one go.

So no more having to waste time and energy into preparing multiple small batches!

There’s an indicator light that alerts you once the brewing is complete.

And this percolator is equipped with a plastic handle and detachable cord.

The former prevents burns while the latter brings more convenience to the table. About the former; since it’s plastic, the door to poor durability is wide open.

So it’s like a gain-lose situation.

But the sleek stainless steel design does indeed set it apart from the rest.

The percolator has a neat mirror chrome coating.

Even this adds to the appeal of the electric coffee pot. So if how your kitchen looks is important to you, you’ll have no complaints.

I’m sure you already by know that the Hamilton Beach 40616 Percolator is perfect for families or those that serve guests quite frequently.

#5 Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite 8-Cup Coffee Percolator

Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite 8-Cup Coffee Percolator Review

Why should you consider buying this super-shiny coffee pot? It’s because the Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite Percolator is a great emergency device.

Emergencies like when you forget to pay your power bill.

It’s a classic piece outfitted with just about all the needful features.

After all, it is a budget-friendly option you’re very likely to purchase instantly.

The percolator is big enough to hold half a gallon of coffee.

This is perfect when you and your family members or roommates consume coffee like it’s going to run out someday.

The coffee pot allows you to watch the tiny bubbles during the brewing process.

These bubbles, by the way, are in a plastic knob, and not glass. You can count this as a minor flaw.

Since it’s not an electric percolator, all you need is a stove, fireplace, or even a grill.

As long as you have any one of those, you’ll never run out of coffee.

What’s even more impressive is that this percolator has the ability to transform the cheapest coffee grounds into a delicacy.

You can prepare strong coffee for 8 cups. It’s got a permanent filter-equipped basket and dishwasher-safe design for easy cleaning.

But what the percolator doesn’t feature is an indicator light.

However, when the coffee pot’s superpower is to extract the complete flavor thus the full potential of coffee, such a setback doesn’t really matter.

#6 Bialetti 06973 Mini Express Stovetop Espresso Percolator

Bialetti 06973 Mini Express Stovetops

Can’t get enough of espresso? Or maybe you just want to buy a mini-sized percolator for your camping adventures? 

Whatever the case, this Bialetti 06973 Mini Express is unbeatable. It functions on a single small burner to pour 2 shots in less than 5 minutes. That’s 2 cups of rich, delicious coffee.

What’s also worth mentioning is the durable, unfussy aluminum construction. 

Much like the common Moka Express. The coffee pot is easy and convenient to use/handle. It fits perfectly well on just about any stovetop. And all you need to do is wait for a little less than 5 minutes.

Bialetti is quite a thoughtful manufacturer. 

The proof of that is the variety of options they offer. This includes color options, size options, and design options. That’s what you get when you choose Italian quality.

On a more personal level, saying “I love coffee shop espresso drinks” is an understatement. But to support this habit means willing to pay around 5 bucks at any local coffee shop. And that’s just not possible. 

So isn’t buying an expensive espresso machine. In that case, what’s the best solution here? It comes in the form of this stovetop espresso percolator.

The coffee pot prepares delicious coffee, no doubt. Your favorite full-city roast gets transformed into espresso you haven’t devoured ever. It tastes exactly like coffee shop espresso. The only problem though is the time-consuming preparation process. But you might grow accustomed to it.

#7 Cuisinart PRC-12 Classic 12-Cup Stainless-Steel Percolator

Cuisinart PRC-12 Classic 12-Cup Stainless-Steel Percolator Review

Here’s another 12 cup-capacity percolator by yet another renowned manufacturer, Cuisinart. But before I go any further, let me make one thing very clear. 

That you cannot prepare coffee less than 4 cups in this. So the PRC-12 percolator is not designed for those who want a quick cup to go first thing in the morning. But for a large crowd, it’s the most reliable.

Just because it’s a 12-cup percolator doesn’t mean the stuff is heavy. It’s light enough for carrying around conveniently.

What else can you expect from this electric stainless steel coffee pot? Well, you can expect the bottom part and handle to remain cool. Even if your coffee is steaming hot! The cord is removable, which means serving becomes easier.

Speaking of serving, the spout is created to avoid leaks and spills. However, it’s not easy to clean. Spotting coffee stains inside is never a pleasant sight. But you can get rid of those if you have a dishwasher.

There is an indicator light you can fall back on to prevent your delicious beverage from burning. I don’t think it’s unreasonable for me to state that the advantages and good features here certainly outnumber the drawbacks.

#8 Coletti Bozeman Percolator Coffee Pot

Coletti Bozeman Percolator Coffee Pot Review

The Bozeman by Coletti is a coffee pot that makes you nostalgic for the traditional method of percolated coffee. 

Products like these are good examples of how not everyone appreciates automatic machines. So it’s time to enjoy full control when it comes to your sacred cup of coffee.

The little coffee pot is made using solid stainless steel. 

There are no aluminum or plastic parts. In fact, this dishwasher-friendly percolator has a glass-equipped cover knob. Talk about long-lasting quality!

Moving on, the convection process and boiling water prepare the hottest coffee. You get as many as 12 cups that remain hot until served. Doesn’t that feel amazing to hear!

The percolator features a rosewood handle. This does more than just lend a classic appeal. It also keeps the handle from heating, which eliminates the likelihood of burning your fingers.

You might also want to know that the Bozeman comes with filters, unlike others on the market. These make sure the coffee grounds don’t fall through. They also reduce the level of oil getting into your coffee, thus lowering cholesterol.

It’s the perfect percolator for daily use. And since it’s not an electric model, you can use it on your stovetop. Although the pot has a rounded base that might not be fit for glass stovetops.

#9 Maxi-Matic Elite Platinum EC-120 12 Cup Percolator

Maxi-Matic Elite Platinum EC-120 12 Cup Percolator Review

The unique mechanism of this Elite Platinum Percolator is the sole reason behind its popularity. The method uses boiling water bubbles and gravity for accomplishing the primary goal. The brand recommends using coarse grind size ground coffee. I just thought you might want to know.

Water in the chamber and coffee in the stainless steel-equipped filter; this percolator once powered on, begins to heat. Water filters through the coffee to start the brewing process. And the bubbles stop once the extreme boiling point has been reached. This is when the indicator light illuminates. And the coffee pot keeps the fresh beverage warm until poured to drink.

Like I mentioned earlier, the filter is made using stainless steel. It works best with a coarse ground to bring forth precision brewing every single time. Like all other percolators on this list, the current one is also outfitted with a handle and base that remain cool.

Moving on to the spout design, it conveniently blocks coffee grounds escaping from the water chamber from entering your cup. And lastly, you can store away the product’s heating base. Without worrying about the power getting all tangled up!

You can brew 12 cups using this thing. So it’s not just the well-made, stainless steel parts that make a huge impact. Nor is it only the fast and easy performance. It’s also the fact that, with this percolator, your coffee actually tastes better even if you like it stronger.

I just didn’t like the lack of a dishwasher-safe label. Had it been there, the complete experience would have been flawless.

#10 Coleman Stainless Steel 12 Cup Percolator

Coleman Stainless Steel 12 Cup Percolator Review

The unique mechanism of this Elite Platinum Percolator is the sole reason behind its popularity. The method uses boiling water bubbles and gravity for accomplishing the primary goal. The brand recommends using coarse grind size ground coffee. I just thought you might want to know.

Water in the chamber and coffee in the stainless steel-equipped filter; this percolator once powered on, begins to heat. Water filters through the coffee to start the brewing process. And the bubbles stop once the extreme boiling point has been reached. This is when the indicator light illuminates. And the coffee pot keeps the fresh beverage warm until poured to drink.

Like I mentioned earlier, the filter is made using stainless steel. It works best with a coarse ground to bring forth precision brewing every single time. Like all other percolators on this list, the current one is also outfitted with a handle and base that remain cool.

Moving on to the spout design, it conveniently blocks coffee grounds escaping from the water chamber from entering your cup. And lastly, you can store away the product’s heating base. Without worrying about the power getting all tangled up!

You can brew 12 cups using this thing. So it’s not just the well-made, stainless steel parts that make a huge impact. Nor is it only the fast and easy performance. It’s also the fact that, with this percolator, your coffee actually tastes better even if you like it stronger.

I just didn’t like the lack of a dishwasher-safe label. Had it been there, the complete experience would have been flawless.

#11 GSI Outdoors Enamelware Percolator

GSI Outdoors Enamelware Percolator Review

Presenting another best camping coffee percolator to satisfy your caffeine cravings outdoors! The GSI Outdoors Enamelware Percolator is a lightweight pot. But it’s plenty heavy-duty for camping situations.

So what sets this one apart from the one above and the rest? The percolator is Kiln-hardened, not once but twice. The temperature at which this hardening takes place is 1100 degrees. But what does this do? It makes the percolator better equipped to withstand chipping and scratches.

The enamel coffee pot here is specifically created for outdoor use. This “enamel” part is what makes the percolator appropriate for fire heating during camping. And, as is expected, the resin cap is heat-resistant and unbreakable. The knob allows you to know when the brewing is done since there’s no indicator light.

How about the number of cups you can prepare? The answer is 8, which, I know, isn’t a lot. But it’s not so hard to overlook this particular letdown. Thanks to the remarkable 3-ply construction of the percolator. What it does is maximize heat distribution when the brewing action is in progress.

In terms of functional aspects, the fancy percolator lives up to basic expectations. Speaking of which, is not expecting the lid hinge to come loose also a basic demand? Of course, it is! In that case, you might be a little disappointed.

#12 Café Brew Collection Stovetop Percolator Glass Coffee Pot

Café Brew Collection Stovetop Percolator Glass Coffee Pots

The first glass percolator on the list, this stovetop coffee pot is of the highest quality. The use of borosilicate glass is proof of that. It’s a dishwasher-safe and stain-resistant model with a leak-free spout.

What you get with it is a basket and lid, trivet, and stem. Whatever is required for brewing a hot cup of coffee on a stove is a part of the package. So if you’re tired of using electric drip pots, since they don’t last very long nor do they keep your coffee hot without burning, you can go for this.

When coffee is perked, it definitely tastes much better. So you know you can raise your expectations with this. I feel obliged to also share with you that the recommended grind size for the current pot is coarse. I don’t see why that is given the small holes of the filter. But you can always remove this filter.

The flavor of the coffee you brew is truly amazing in comparison to the traditional drip method. The hot beverage tastes very smooth without any bitterness. Along the same lines, you can actually view your coffee strength. In that case, the longer you allow it to perk, the darker it gets.

It’s a pretty convenient option for travel as well. Plus, the price makes it all so much better.

Best Coffee Percolators: The Ultimate Buyer’s Guide

percolator coffee

Why You Should Consider Buying a Coffee Percolator

You see a coffee percolator is a fine thing. It is not only one of the most effective ways to brew coffee. But it also happens to be one of the simplest. 

Percolators are a big hit among hikers and campers and you’ll always see them using a percolator when outdoors.

Percolators are versatile in the way that you use them. You can power them with a power outlet and other sources of heat. 

They give you the best coffee taste and aroma every time. It offers a different coffee flavor and brewing method than drip coffee, but not in a bad way.

A percolator brings out the freshest and most aromatic smell of coffee. If you’re a coffee nut, buying the best coffee percolator is essential.

And another good reason is space. 

Percolators hardly take up any space on your kitchen counter. It’s in a little pot that the coffee brews itself but the smell reaches everywhere. 

All you need is a power outlet and you’re good to go.

If you ask me, a percolator is good for single-person use. When you live alone, you don’t want high-maintenance kitchen appliances. 

A percolator is easy to care for, maintain, and use.

Choosing Different Brewing Methods for Coffee

There’s nothing better than starting your day with a steaming cup of coffee. So it’s on you to improve the way you brew coffee. With so many different brewing methods, it’s a matter of personal preference which you like best.

A drip coffee pot is a common appliance in most homes. They are simple, efficient, and durable. So if you don’t want to invest in an expensive espresso machine, a drip coffee maker brings you closest to it. 

It works by heating water and creating steam inside the machine. The hot water runs through the coffee grounds, which then drips coffee into your cup or pot. To let the steam out created by the heating of water, a tube system has an outlet near the drip area.

Unlike a percolator, a single drip cycle is enough to disperse a single shot of freshly-brewed coffee.

Moka Pot

A Moka pot is divided into three unique chambers. The top part is where the brewed coffee collects, the middle part is where you keep the coffee grounds, and the bottom part is the water chamber.

It uses steam to create pressure inside the water chamber. When the pressure reaches a high, the water is pushed upwards to seep through the coffee. As a result, the top chamber holds brewed and rich coffee that’s right to serve!

You’d want a Moka pot to save space, money, and time. A Moka pot takes 6-8 minutes to brew coffee. Plus, they’re super durable and easy to maintain.

A French press is good-looking and functional. It can make any kitchen look fancy, luxurious, and classy. Depending upon your needs, you can buy stainless steel, plastic, ceramic, or glass beaker.

The best thing about a French press is that you can alter its brewing strength. From a light roast to a dark roast, you can put in only how much you want. And keep pouring yourself a coffee for the rest of the day.

A French press consists of a metal filter, not a paper one. This allows the coffee to seep through along with its aromatic scent and oils. 

So you’re not only drinking flavorful and rich coffee. But you’re also taking in its antioxidants and other nutrients.

Choosing the Best Coffee Percolator

Coffee Percolators

Type

What type of percolator do you need? While gravity percolators are the most traditional choice, pressure percolators are simple and efficient.

Gravity percolators brew coffee work from the top down. There’s a little nozzle that filters the coffee from the bottom chamber. So the grounds stay in and the brewed coffee gets out.

Compared with gravity percolators, pressure does not over-extract coffee. You can keep the coffee in the percolator for as long as you.

And it won’t taste bitter or too strong. Having said that, gravity percolators are harder to maintain as you have to extract the metal filter each time you pour a cup. This is not true for pressure percolators as it consists of three separate chambers.

Capacity

What’s your brewing size? Is it for one person or a group of people? Percolators are fantastic because they can brew up to 12 cups of coffee. If you’re a coffee nut and drink more than 6 cups of coffee a day, having a percolator would be a godsend.

The high capacity allows you to add milk or cream or syrup separately while you get a rich dose of caffeine in your coffee serving.

Electric vs Stovetop

Type of Percolator

Stovetop percolators are more common as they’re easier to use and portable. Stovetop percolators are manual and you can use them anywhere you want. As long as you have a heat source like a gas grill or stove.

Electric, on the other hand, are modern and automatic. If you want quick and effortless functionality, go for an electric percolator. Electric percolators come with automatic functions like a timer, auto on/off, and cycle settings.

Materials

You have to choose between an enamel and stainless steel percolator. For camping, a heavy-duty stainless steel percolator is essential. It won’t break, crack, or feel fragile. The tube and basket are made up of durable materials.

If it is a stovetop percolator, the flames won’t spoil the coating of the pot. So there would be no blackening of the metal.

Enamel percolators are best for at-home use, especially as electric percolators. They add both style and function to coffee brewing.

How Does a Percolator Work?

How Percolators work

A percolator consists of multiple chambers. For the ground coffee, cold water, hot water, and the heating source.

Starting from the top chamber which holds the ground coffee, there’s a filter at the bottom of that chamber.

In it, is a tube-like nozzle that lets out heated water that is stored under the ground coffee chamber. Surrounding that chamber, from all sides, is another chamber which holds cold water. And underneath that is a chamber for the heating source.

The process of brewing coffee in the best coffee percolator is like this.

  1. 1

    When you start the percolator, it creates pressure inside the hot water chamber. The tiny bubbles formed due to constant boiling force the water up into the coffee grounds

  2. 2

    The hot water sprays into the ground coffee, seeping through it and falling back into the cool water chamber.

  3. 3

    The spreader cover, inside the ground coffee chamber, has holes of various sizes. This helps in the distribution and saturation of coffee. And it also makes sure nothing hot water doesn’t splash to the lid of the percolator.

If your percolator doesn’t have a proper pumping tube system, do not buy it. The cool water chamber must be properly sealed to hold coffee. 

And the perforated spreader cover should maximum coffee extraction while creating a barrier between the top of the chamber to prevent splashes.

Cleaning a Coffee Percolator

Your coffee will taste only as good as you keep your percolator. 

The ideal time to clean a coffee percolator (2) is once in a month. 

But this also depends on how often you use it. If you use it regularly, then twice in a month. However, for occasional users, monthly deep cleansing is ideal to get rid of mold.

What you need:

  • Brush
  • Baking soda
  • Vinegar
  • Water

Method:

  • Make sure you fill the water chamber with water.
  • Add 2-3 tablespoons of baking soda in the ground coffee chamber.
  • Let the percolator run a single cycle. Do not drain the water after it’s done.
  • Gently scrub the inside with a brush.
  • Remove the water and fill with half-vinegar and half-water mixture. Run another cycle and discard the water.
  • To remove the scent of vinegar, run another cycle with fresh water in the chamber

Final Note

Percolation; you’ll either love it or hate it. 

The good thing about this method is that it prepares hot, strong coffee in less than 5 minutes. 

And the bad part is that it tends to burn your coffee. 

But you can eliminate the negative aspect if you pick the best coffee percolator. 

The 12 I’ve reviewed in the article give you steaming and strong coffee, no doubt, without burning it.

Both the electric and stovetop options offer results that don’t disappoint or discourage you from percolating coffee. That’s for sure. 

All you have to do is ensure that you make a well-informed decision. And the guide section precisely helps you with that.

Last Updated on